Transaction Cost Economics and Industry Maturity in IT Outsourcing: a Meta-Analysis of Contract Type Choice
نویسندگان
چکیده
Recent reviews of the information technology outsourcing (ITO) literature report high variance in research results when Transaction Cost Economics (TCE) is used as the analytical framework. Informed by ITO market developments, including increasing commoditisation, market consolidation, and market transparency, we develop an explanation for these mixed results contingent on ITO industry maturity. We adopt meta-analysis to show that ITO industry maturity significantly explains variance in the choice of contract type (time and materials vs. fixed price) in ITO projects. Our results suggest that TCE is relevant to explain the choice of contract type in the emerging phase of the ITO industry, but not in its current mature phase. We conclude that a TCE-based analytical framework is not well suited for the study of ITO in the current mature industry phase. Instead, we propose that an “endogenous” ITO theory should be developed that focuses on differences in client behaviour rather than vendor behaviour.
منابع مشابه
Contracts: Theory and Evidence
The information systems outsourcing market has seen rapid growth. Companies are increasingly choosing to outsource many of their information systems activities to services firms rather than sourcing them internally. This trend is inconsistent with the predictions of some of the published literature which point to the high costs of using an outside market. These articles, based on transaction co...
متن کاملValue Creation and Value Claiming in Make-Or-Buy Decisions: Evidence from the Application Service Industry
Transaction value analysis (TVA) integrates the concepts of resource heterogeneity and transaction cost economics into a single framework, which emphasizes both value creation and value claiming in firms vertical integration decisions. Using a TVA perspective, we develop hypotheses to explain the firms intent to outsource application services. A sample of 178 firms in the publishing and print...
متن کاملContract Design Choices and the Balance of Ex Ante and Ex Post Transaction Costs in Software Development Outsourcing
This paper examines multiple contract design choices in the context of transaction and relational attributes and consequent ex ante and ex post transaction costs. It focuses on two understudied themes in the IT outsourcing literature. First, while the literature is predominantly concerned with opportunism and consequent ex post hazard costs that contracts can safeguard against, parties to a con...
متن کاملThe Role of Contract Negotiation and Industry Structure in Production Outsourcing
D espite the spread of cost-driven outsourcing practices, academic research cautions that suppliers’ cost advantage may weaken manufacturers’ bargaining positions in negotiating outsourcing agreements, thereby hurting their profitability. In this study, we attempt to further understand the strategic impact of low-cost outsourcing on manufacturers’ profitability by investigating the contractual ...
متن کاملIT Offshore Outsourcing: Contingency and Strategies
This article explores the IT offshore outsourcing phenomena and discusses the predictors of firm’s adoption level of offshoring practice. The authors draw on transaction cost economics, culture theories, integrated social contract theory, and institutional theory to examine the offshore outsourcing impetuses and investigate the related research issues. The multitheoretic lens highlights the int...
متن کامل